Hi all,
I'm new to this tribe, my son Kiran is 14 months old. We just moved to Concord (CA) and I found a new pediatrician who I thought would be fine, but boy was I wrong. Because he was only 18 pounds just after a year, she seemed pretty alarmed and wanted to run all kinds of tests. I resisted and told her that I thought it was just because of his genetics (his daddy and I are both underweight). She disagreed and had me come back every three weeks and see a physical therapist to teach him how to eat more without my help. He has since learned to self-feed and she still isn't happy, as he only gained a few ounces. I really don't see a problem--he is proportionate to his height, and has tons of energy. I was the same size at his age and have struggled all my life to gain weight.
So--do any of you have recommendations for some good, supportive pediatricians in Concord/Walnut Creek/Pleasant Hill? I'd love to take him to a homeopath for his well-checks, but insurance doesn't cover that and we're on a tight budget. She also strongly recommended that I stop nursing him because he is a year old. Umm...WOW. That's when I knew I had to switch doctors.
I'm new to this tribe, my son Kiran is 14 months old. We just moved to Concord (CA) and I found a new pediatrician who I thought would be fine, but boy was I wrong. Because he was only 18 pounds just after a year, she seemed pretty alarmed and wanted to run all kinds of tests. I resisted and told her that I thought it was just because of his genetics (his daddy and I are both underweight). She disagreed and had me come back every three weeks and see a physical therapist to teach him how to eat more without my help. He has since learned to self-feed and she still isn't happy, as he only gained a few ounces. I really don't see a problem--he is proportionate to his height, and has tons of energy. I was the same size at his age and have struggled all my life to gain weight.
So--do any of you have recommendations for some good, supportive pediatricians in Concord/Walnut Creek/Pleasant Hill? I'd love to take him to a homeopath for his well-checks, but insurance doesn't cover that and we're on a tight budget. She also strongly recommended that I stop nursing him because he is a year old. Umm...WOW. That's when I knew I had to switch doctors.
-
Re: Doctor's advice...
Fri, May 9, 2008 - 11:34 AMIm sorry, I have no recommendations. Def. switch doctors. My kids were the same, really 'light' at that age but their doctors werent worried and neither was I because they developed fine and were where they should be otherwise. That weight is not even in the 'unhealthy' range yet at ALL. -
-
Re: Doctor's advice...
Fri, May 9, 2008 - 12:09 PMThis is kind of a radical idea but you could just stop taking him for well visits. I live in a very remote rural area and there is only one health care provider available. She made similar recommendations about Sam so we just stopped going to see her. If he has an emergency we'll go there if we can't get to the hospital, but otherwise my kid is healthy and I came to the conclusion that there isn't any reason to keep going to the doctor. It's their job to look for anything that might be wrong, that's what they're trained to do and if I consult them, that's what I should expect. But I decided don't like the idea of someone looking for what's wrong with my kid. Many of them have radically different ideas about what's healthy for a child than I do. It's far too stressful to go through that all the time. My son is thin and tall, still nurses a lot and eats very little, is very energetic and quite healthy.
I have wished we did have a great pediatrician so we could just check in every now and then, but I'd rather just take my chances than expose my son to our local prac's fearmongering style of medicine. All we get from that is stress and anxiety, which everyone knows is bad for your health!
I wish you good luck in finding a compatible medical person. -
-
Re: Doctor's advice...
Fri, May 9, 2008 - 7:55 PMI have a child who is constitutionally very slender, but has always been very healthy. there is a strong genetic connection for us too...im my family,we tend to be small and fairly thin until around age 30 or 35. and her biological father,who is not really involved in her life, has been quite slender/skinn but very strong and muscular his whole life.
Idecided against the regular well-child visits too.. there are pediatircians I reall respect who I have heard are very supportive of alternative and complementary well-childcare...but I found that for a healthy person,including a baby,it isn't hat necessary to"manage" and "doctor."
Irecently found a naturopathic doctor in partnership with an MD that,coincidentally,I;ve known since my college days over 30 eyars ago...but they don;t have a family practice there. you might have to look around.for a doctorwho respects thediversityofhuman growth...or depending onyour comfort levels and your child's generalhealth,youmight want to b your child's main health care provider (you are anyway.) -
-
Re: Doctor's advice...
Sat, May 10, 2008 - 1:26 PMdump that doctor and don't think twice about it! She told you to stop nursing because your child is 1? Then she isn't even practicing up to the standards set by the American Academy of Pediatrics, or Family Practitioners. Seriously.
If you're comfortable with it, don't do the "well child" checks, especially if you know your child *is* well. But after being told the things she's told you, i'd still want a different doctor no matter how rarely i went to see her. -
-
Re: Doctor's advice...
Sun, May 11, 2008 - 1:31 AMThank you all for your posts--I am going to dump her, I've decided. I think what really did it was her breastfeeding advice. I'm also going to ask around for some homeopathic practitioners, since I'd probably be saving money if I only take him for the occasional wellcheck compared to regular checkups that cost $25 a copay and the usual bills I get after the fact that my insurance didn't cover. I just couldn't believe she would be so combative and it does help to hear that some of you don't do the wellchecks, as you yourself can see that your child is healthy!
-
Re: Doctor's advice...
Mon, May 12, 2008 - 2:27 PMsomething else that doesn't make sense- a baby's weight at one year should be roughly 3 times their birth weight, not a specific set goal. So a set number isn't really making sense here.
-
-
-
-
-
Re: Doctor's advice...
Mon, May 12, 2008 - 9:47 AMwoah...
my daughter is 13 months and weighs 19 lbs and for the most part is still exclusively breastfed. heh =\ so yeah sounds like a new pedi is in order!!